Intent Is Not a Defense. Silence Is a Choice.

By Dave McGrath

Originally published as a Facebook post on February 10, 2026.

Intent Is Not a Defense. Silence Is a Choice. A common defense of the Order of the Arrow is that its founders meant well. That their intent was to honor Native Americans, not exploit them. Intent is not the standard. Impact is. Good intentions do not transform false claims into truth. They do not create consent where none existed. And they do not justify an institution continuing a harmful practice after that harm has been clearly identified. Invoking the Baden-Powell era is not a defense either. Scouting was founded to build character, not to fossilize early-20th-century ignorance and call it tradition.

Illustration of a funeral scene at sunset: a casket draped with the American flag and an Order of the Arrow banner, a folded flag resting on the casket, a wreath reading 'The Order of the Arrow 1915 – 2026,' with uniformed trumpet players and a waving American flag behind.
Funeral-scene illustration prepared for the essay — the author’s argument that the honorable exit is ceremony and closure, not rebranding. Illustration prepared for the Independent Office of BSA Accountability. Images in this post are evidence retained under our historical images policy.

Here is the uncomfortable truth every OA member and former member must face. The OA National Office effectively ended its own claim to Native American authorization when it ordered lodges to obtain local Tribal authorization that it knew, or should have known, would not be granted. That directive was not reconciliation. It was a quiet admission that the previous claims of authorization were indefensible.

When consent became a requirement, the claim collapsed. From that moment forward, the continuation of OA Native American practices depended on inertia, denial, and silence. A trustworthy use of Native American heritage would require legitimate local Tribal authority, explicit permission, and ongoing, revocable consent. That is the standard this Office’s compliance framework sets — and OA’s own policy points the same direction. OA has never met it. What may have begun in 1915 as ignorance continues in 2026 as choice. At some point, they didn’t know better becomes they refused to do better.

By continuing to participate, defend, minimize, or remain silent, OA members and former members share responsibility for the dishonor inflicted on Native communities, on Scouting America, and on the youth taught to confuse loyalty with integrity.

Intent may explain the past. It does not excuse the present. The only honorable exit left is not rebranding, revision, or another explanatory memo. It is ceremony and closure. 24 notes of military Taps. The colors lowered. Silence. An acknowledgment that this chapter ends not because it was misunderstood, but because it was wrong. Institutions that claim honor must be willing to lay down what cannot be justified. Anything less is not tradition. It is refusal.

Footnotes

Appended October 24, 2026, under the Office’s evidence-note program. The essay text above stands as originally published; these notes document its factual claims.

  1. National Order of the Arrow, “Our History,” oa-scouting.org: “In 1915, Camp Director E. Urner Goodman and Assistant Camp Director Carroll A. Edson searched for a way to recognize select campers for their cheerful sprits of service at Treasure Island Scout Camp in the Delaware River. Goodman and Edson founded the Order of the Arrow when they held the first Ordeal Ceremony on July 16th of that year.” https://oa-scouting.org/history
  2. National Order of the Arrow, “Policy Update: Changes Regarding American Indian Programming,” oa-scouting.org (December 2022). On December 28, 2022, the national OA committee accepted its task force’s recommendation that any program involving American Indian traditions “must be done in conjunction with a state or federally recognized tribe”; beginning January 1, 2026, only lodges with a formal relationship with a state or federally recognized tribe may engage in American Indian programming; the task force concluded that the determination of how to best and appropriately incorporate American Indian culture “belongs to a local tribe, not the Order of the Arrow.” The OA’s AIA policy FAQ states the mechanism: “Lodges who do not have a written agreement with a tribe will need to cease incorporating American Indian traditions in their program after January 1, 2026 or until such time as they have a written agreement in place.” https://oa-scouting.org/article/policy-update-changes-regarding-american-indian-programming and https://oa-scouting.org/resources/aia-policy
Loading spinner