By Dave McGrath
Originally published as a Facebook post on May 26, 2026.

In discussions about whether Scouting America (formerly the BSA) is truly welcoming to LGBT youth and families, people often point to the national policy changes that occurred after 2013. Those changes were real. But there is another layer to the issue that deserves careful examination: the actual chartered organizations that operate local Scout units.
I decided to look at the 2013 chartered organization data and recast it through a different lens.
The original dataset comes from BSA/Scouting America reporting and summaries of chartered organizations by membership share. In 2013, approximately 65% of BSA units were chartered through religious organizations (about 55% of youth membership by independent estimates) and approximately 35% through secular or civic organizations.
I then removed two unusually large and ideologically distinctive blocs from the 2013 numbers:
The LDS Church (roughly 18% of the 2.4 million total membership in 2013)
Southern Baptist affiliated churches (roughly 3-4%)
Note: the LDS Church ended its BSA chartering relationship entirely on December 31, 2019 — this analysis uses 2013 data.
Why remove them? Because they were so disproportionately large that they obscured the ideological composition of the rest of the organization.
From there, the remaining chartered organizations were grouped into categories:
Religious organizations that were institutionally Open and Affirming toward LGBT people in 2013
Religious organizations that were not Open and Affirming
Secular/civic organizations likely institutionally affirming or operating under nondiscrimination norms
Secular/civic organizations that were neutral, mixed, or socially conservative
This required judgment calls. For example:
- The Episcopal Church, UCC, PCUSA, ELCA, Reform Judaism, etc. were treated as affirming.
- Catholic dioceses, evangelical churches, Church of Christ, Nazarene, Assemblies of God, conservative Methodist bodies, etc. were treated as non-affirming in 2013.
- Public schools and many PTAs were treated as institutionally affirming or inclusion-oriented because of prevailing nondiscrimination expectations at the time.
- Veteran organizations, independent civic clubs, and “Friends of Troop” committees were treated as mixed or uncertain unless clearly identifiable.
The recast results were approximately:
17% – Religious: Open and Affirming
41% – Religious: Not Open and Affirming
26% – Secular: Open and Affirming
16% – Secular: Neutral / Mixed / Unclear
Combined together, that suggests that after removing LDS and Southern Baptist sponsorship, the remaining BSA ecosystem in 2013 was still roughly:
- 43% institutionally Affirming
- 41% institutionally non-affirming
- 16% unclear or mixed
That is a much more divided picture than either side of the debate often presents.
And that leads to an important caution.
Scouting America today often presents itself publicly as fully welcoming and inclusive. At the national level, many formal barriers have indeed been removed. But local Scouting is still delivered through chartered organizations and local adult culture. Many of those organizations remain socially conservative institutions, including churches and some secular civic groups.
So for gay youth, gay adults, or LGBT families, caution and due diligence are still warranted. The lived experience of a Scout unit can vary dramatically depending on the sponsoring organization, local leadership culture, and community norms.
A rainbow logo on a national website does not necessarily mean a local troop or pack is genuinely affirming, emotionally safe, or socially welcoming.
Some units absolutely are.
Some clearly are not.
And in the experience of this author, many organizations categorized as “neutral,” “mixed,” or “unclear” should realistically be approached as non-affirming unless they have made explicit public statements supporting LGBT inclusion. In practice, silence usually benefits the status quo. Organizations that are genuinely affirming typically say so openly and unambiguously.
For LGBT families evaluating a Scout unit, the safest assumption is not that a unit is affirming unless proven otherwise, but that careful local investigation is necessary before trusting national branding or generalized claims of inclusiveness.
For gay families? They cannot afford to assume – childhood happens once and spiritual abuse is real. Those stats look like this to us with gay kids (approximate):
- 𝟰𝟯% 𝗶𝗻𝘀𝘁𝗶𝘁𝘂𝘁𝗶𝗼𝗻𝗮𝗹𝗹𝘆 𝗔𝗳𝗳𝗶𝗿𝗺𝗶𝗻𝗴
- 𝟱𝟳% 𝗶𝗻𝘀𝘁𝗶𝘁𝘂𝘁𝗶𝗼𝗻𝗮𝗹𝗹𝘆 𝗻𝗼𝗻-A𝗳𝗳𝗶𝗿𝗺𝗶𝗻𝗴 (41% explicitly + the 16% unclear or mixed)
Question to you: it’s been 13 years since the end of the BSA official gay-ban against youth. And 11 years since the BSA ban against gay adults. What do you think the current stats look like?
Footnotes
Appended October 24, 2026, under the Office’s evidence-note program. The essay text above stands as originally published; these notes document its factual claims.
- The 2013 base dataset. Boy Scouts of America, “Chartered Organizations and the Boy Scouts of America” (March 2014), as reproduced in “Chartered organizations of Scouting America.” The table’s headline rows: The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, 37,933 units (36.99%) and 437,160 youth (17.98%); United Methodist Church, 10,703 units and 349,614 youth; Catholic Church, 8,131 units and 259,297 youth; “Baptist churches,” 3,532 units (3.44%) and 91,526 youth (3.76%). Summing the table’s religious rows gives approximately 73% of units and approximately 65% of youth chartered through religious organizations, with the remainder through civic and educational organizations. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chartered_organizations_of_Scouting_America
- The LDS share. The same table: 437,160 LDS youth out of a total youth membership of about 2.43 million, i.e. 17.98%, and 36.99% of units. Contemporary reporting matches: “In 2013, more than a third (37 percent) of troops were LDS sponsored, accounting for 18 percent of the BSA’s 2.4 million total membership.” Sojourners, “Mormon Church Sticking with Boy Scouts” (August 27, 2015). https://sojo.net/articles/mormon-church-sticking-boy-scouts
- The Baptist share. The table’s row is “Baptist churches” generally — 3,532 units (3.44%) and 91,526 youth (3.76%) — not broken out by convention; the essay’s “Southern Baptist affiliated churches (roughly 3-4%)” tracks the row’s youth share. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chartered_organizations_of_Scouting_America
- The LDS exit. Joint statement of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints and the Boy Scouts of America (May 8, 2018): “We have jointly determined that, effective on December 31, 2019, the Church will conclude its relationship as a chartered organization with all Scouting programs around the world.” https://www.churchofjesuschrist.org/youth/childrenandyouth/joint-church-bsa-statement?lang=eng
- The recast is the author’s own analysis, and the essay says so. After removing the LDS and Baptist blocs from the 2013 data, the author grouped the remaining chartered organizations by the categories the essay names — religious organizations institutionally Open and Affirming toward LGBT people in 2013, religious organizations not Open and Affirming, secular/civic organizations likely affirming or operating under nondiscrimination norms, and secular/civic organizations neutral, mixed, or socially conservative — applying the judgment calls the essay states (Episcopal Church, UCC, PCUSA, ELCA, Reform Judaism and others treated as affirming; Catholic dioceses, evangelical churches, Church of Christ, Nazarene, Assemblies of God, conservative Methodist bodies and others treated as non-affirming in 2013; public schools and many PTAs treated as inclusion-oriented; veteran organizations, independent civic clubs, and “Friends of Troop” committees treated as mixed or uncertain unless clearly identifiable). The recast results the essay reports: 17% Religious: Open and Affirming; 41% Religious: Not Open and Affirming; 26% Secular: Open and Affirming; 16% Secular: Neutral / Mixed / Unclear. Base table: note 1.
- The combined figures are arithmetic on the recast, not a separate dataset: 17% + 26% = 43% institutionally Affirming; 41% institutionally non-affirming; 16% unclear or mixed; and 41% + 16% = 57% institutionally non-affirming on the essay’s closing rule that the unclear or mixed bloc is approached as non-affirming unless an organization has made an explicit public statement supporting LGBT inclusion.
- The policy timeline behind the essay’s framing and its closing question. Youth: on May 23, 2013, the BSA National Council voted (more than 60% in favor) to rescind the ban on openly homosexual youth; effective January 1, 2014, “No youth may be denied membership in the Boy Scouts of America on the basis of sexual orientation or preference alone.” Adults: on July 27, 2015, the National Executive Board voted 45-12 to end the ban on openly gay adult leaders and employees, effective immediately, while religious chartered organizations retained the right to use religious beliefs as criteria for selecting adult leaders. Transgender youth: on January 30, 2017, the BSA announced it would accept and register youth in Cub and Boy Scout programs based on the gender identity indicated on the application, replacing the birth-certificate rule. Name: announced May 7, 2024, the Boy Scouts of America rebranded as Scouting America effective February 8, 2025. The essay’s closing “13 years” counts from the May 2013 youth vote; its “11 years” counts from the July 2015 adult vote. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boy_Scouts_of_America_membership_controversies and https://www.scoutingnewsroom.org/boy-scouts-of-america-to-become-scouting-america/
- Original publication: Dave McGrath, “Truly Welcoming to LGBT Youth?,” Facebook, May 26, 2026, as stated on the essay page itself. No permalink to the original post appears on the page.