Private Discrimination on the Public Dime

By Dave McGrath

Originally published as a Facebook post on December 27, 2025.

Poster: 'PRIVATE ORGANIZATION' at top; a BSA-style fleur-de-lis with an eagle over a USFS/BLM topographic map and forest on the left and a guard tower with chain-link fence on the right; a red diagonal stamp reads 'PUBLIC PRIVILEGE'; bottom text reads 'PUBLIC PRIVILEGE IS CONDITIONAL.'
Graphic as originally published with the December 2025 Facebook post. Images in this post are evidence retained under our historical images policy.

BSA Private Discrimination on the Public Dime

Why “we’re private” has never meant “we’re untouchable”

Let’s dispense with the talking point up front.

Yes, the Boy Scouts of America is a private organization.

No, that has never entitled it to public privilege without public accountability.

What’s being defended isn’t “freedom of association.”

What’s being defended is the continuation of extraordinary public benefits after the civic justification for those benefits collapsed.

That’s not how the law works.


Count I: Public land underwriting

For decades—especially across the western United States—BSA councils held Scout camps on $1-per-year, long-term, exclusive leases from municipalities — most famously San Diego’s Balboa Park, where the Desert Pacific Council held 18 acres for $1 a year for nearly 70 years until a federal court ruled the arrangement unconstitutional in 2003.

These were not casual permits.

They were municipal land grants at nominal cost, justified because Scouting was treated as a quasi-civic institution serving the public at large.[1]

When BSA’s exclusionary membership policies became legally and publicly untenable, those preferential leases were terminated.[2]

That wasn’t “cancel culture.”

That was public land policy colliding with public anti-discrimination law.

Private organizations may discriminate.

Public land may not subsidize that discrimination.


Count II: Statutory access to military installations

BSA is not just another nonprofit.

Congress and the Department of Defense granted it special statutory and regulatory access to military bases, facilities, and logistical support for jamborees, training, and troop activities.[3]

That access exists only insofar as it complies with other federal law, including the Civil Rights Act and equal-access requirements governing federally supported programs and facilities.[4]

When a private organization’s membership rules conflict with those laws, the privilege yields.

No one is banning Scouting.

The government is simply no longer required to privilege it.

That is not ideology.

That is black-letter civil law.


Count III: “Citizenship in the Nation” as a legal claim

BSA does not merely claim to teach “values.”

It explicitly teaches constitutional principles, equal protection, and civil-rights jurisprudence through Citizenship in the Nation and related programming.

When an organization claims to teach civic equality while enforcing belief- or identity-based exclusions that contradict those principles, it invites scrutiny.

That scrutiny is not persecution.

It is accountability to the standards the organization itself invokes.

The distinction critics refuse to acknowledge

Being legally private does not guarantee public privilege.

Privilege is conditional.

It always has been.

Churches may use public parks.

They do not receive exclusive, decades-long public land leases.

Nonprofits may teach civic virtue.

They do not receive statutory access to military installations by default.

Scouting once did—because it was treated as broadly inclusive and civic in character.

As that premise eroded, so did the justification for special access.

That is not destruction.

It is the normal operation of constitutional democracy.

Scouting is free to draw any line it wants.

The public is equally free to decide whether that line merits public support.

That isn’t activism.

That is Citizenship in the Nation—applied, not recited.


Inline references (for those who prefer facts to slogans)

[1] Municipal land grants at nominal cost — e.g., City of San Diego / Desert Pacific Council, Balboa Park: 18 acres at $1/year for nearly 70 years (plus a Fiesta Island aquatic facility); ruled unconstitutional by Federal District Court Judge Napoleon Jones, July 2003; terminated via settlement, January 2004 (ACLU of San Diego). Federal land authorities operate similar frameworks: U.S. Forest Service special-use permit authority; BLM Recreation and Public Purposes Act (43 U.S.C. § 869 et seq.).

[2] Boy Scouts of America v. Dale, 530 U.S. 640 (2000) (association rights recognized; public subsidy consequences left intact)

[3] 36 U.S.C. § 30901 et seq. (Congressional charter); DoD support policies for youth organizations

[4] Civil Rights Act of 1964, Titles II & VI (42 U.S.C. §§ 2000a, 2000d); DoD equal-access and non-discrimination regulations

Footnotes

Appended October 24, 2026, under the Office’s evidence-note program. The essay text above stands as originally published; these notes document its factual claims.

  1. The Balboa Park leases — the essay’s reference [1], verified. The City of San Diego leased Camp Balboa in Balboa Park to the Desert Pacific Council beginning in 1957 under a 50-year lease at $1 per year; the American Civil Liberties Union’s settlement statement describes it as 18 acres of prime park property for $1 per year, plus free use of an aquatic facility on city-owned Fiesta Island in Mission Bay (a half-acre parcel leased in 1987 for 25 years, under which the council built the San Diego Youth Aquatic Center in lieu of cash rent). In July 2003, Judge Napoleon A. Jones Jr. of the United States District Court for the Southern District of California ruled the Balboa Park lease unconstitutional under the federal Establishment Clause and California’s No Aid and No Preference Clauses. Barnes-Wallace v. Boy Scouts of America, 275 F. Supp. 2d 1259 (S.D. Cal. 2003). On January 8, 2004, the ACLU announced a settlement with the city under which the city would ask Judge Jones to enter a final judgment on that ruling and then give the Scouts notice that the Balboa Park lease had terminated and their interest in the property had expired; under the terms of the 2002 Camp Balboa lease, the term tenancy was converted to a month-to-month tenancy. The essay’s federal-framework citations are general authorities, not BSA-specific subsidies: U.S. Forest Service special-use permit authority (36 C.F.R. pt. 251) and the Bureau of Land Management’s Recreation and Public Purposes Act (43 U.S.C. §§ 869 et seq.). https://www.aclu.org/press-releases/aclu-san-diego-secures-landmark-settlement-boy-scout-lease-case?redirect=cpredirect/11950 and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barnes-Wallace_v._Boy_Scouts_of_America
  2. The later history of the Balboa Park case, which the essay’s account stops short of. The settlement provided for the Scouts’ continued ability to use the facilities. On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit reversed the district court’s ruling: on December 20, 2012, it held that the leases do not violate the No Aid Clause or the No Preference Clause of the California Constitution or the federal Establishment Clause, finding no evidence the city’s purpose in leasing the properties was to advance religion and abundant evidence its purpose was to provide facilities and services for youth activities (Judge William C. Canby Jr.). In 2013 the plaintiffs decided not to appeal further, ending the suit. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barnes-Wallace_v._Boy_Scouts_of_America
  3. The essay’s reference [2], and its proper anchor. Boy Scouts of America v. Dale, 530 U.S. 640 (2000), recognized the organization’s First Amendment expressive-association right to exclude a gay assistant scoutmaster; it did not rule on public benefits or subsidies, leaving those questions to other law. The case supports the essay’s sentence “Private organizations may discriminate,” not the lease-termination sentence to which [2] is attached in the text. https://law.onecle.com/ussc/530/530us665.html
  4. The congressional charter — the essay’s reference [3], first half. The Boy Scouts of America holds a federal charter, originally granted June 15, 1916, and now codified at 36 U.S.C. §§ 30901–30908 (Pub. L. 105–225, Aug. 12, 1998). Section 30901 makes the corporation a body corporate and politic of the District of Columbia with perpetual existence; section 30902 states its purposes. https://www.scouting.org/about/governance/charter/ and https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCODE-2011-title36/html/USCODE-2011-title36-subtitleII-partB-chap309.htm
  5. Military support for jamborees — the essay’s reference [3], second half, stated precisely. The Secretary of Defense is authorized by 10 U.S.C. § 2554 to lend equipment to the Boy Scouts of America and, without reimbursement, to furnish services and expendable medical supplies for national or world Boy Scout Jamborees, and to make military installations available for those gatherings. The Support Our Scouts Act of 2005 (Pub. L. 109–148, § 8126) further provides that no federal law shall be construed to limit a federal agency from providing support for a youth organization below the prior fiscal year’s level, and that the Secretary of Defense shall provide at least the same level of support for a national or world Boy Scout Jamboree as was provided for the preceding one. The statutory entitlement is jamboree-specific. https://www.casemine.com/act/us/591974b4add7b05bd4d9485f and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Support_Our_Scouts_Act
  6. The civil-rights statutes and the Defense regulation — the essay’s reference [4]. Title II of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, 42 U.S.C. § 2000a, bars discrimination in places of public accommodation; Title VI, 42 U.S.C. § 2000d, bars discrimination on the ground of race, color, or national origin under any program or activity receiving federal financial assistance. The Department of Defense’s Title VI regulation, 32 C.F.R. pt. 195, effectuates Title VI for Defense components: section 195.1 provides that no person in the United States shall, on the ground of race, color, or national origin, be excluded from participation in, be denied the benefits of, or be otherwise subjected to discrimination under any program or activity receiving federal financial assistance from any component of the Department of Defense. https://chanrobles.com/usa/uslaws/cfr/title32/32-2.1.1.1.5.php
  7. Citizenship in the Nation. The Eagle-required merit badge’s requirements (2022 revision) include discussing the Declaration of Independence, the Bill of Rights and the 14th Amendment, and the traditional motto “E Pluribus Unum”; listing the three branches of government and explaining how each branch checks and balances the others; and listing the six purposes for creating the Constitution set forth in the Preamble. The equal-protection teaching the essay invokes sits in the 14th Amendment requirement. https://boyscouttrail.com/boy-scouts/meritbadges/citizenship-in-the-nation-merit-badge.asp
  8. Original publication: Dave McGrath, “Private Discrimination on the Public Dime,” Facebook, December 27, 2025, as stated on the essay page itself. https://facebook.com/groups/bravescouters/permalink/3076938705824853/
Loading spinner