Home

The Office of BSA Accountability is an independent research and public accountability initiative examining the gap between Scouting America’s stated principles, its national policies, and the practices it permits.

Latest Findings

The Photographer Speaks — An analysis of 299 comments on four warbonnet photos, assessed against the OA’s January 2026 policy.

Accountability begins with the Scout Law.

Scouting America teaches young people to be trustworthy, loyal, helpful, friendly, courteous, kind, obedient, cheerful, thrifty, brave, clean, and reverent.

Its institutions should be held to those same standards.

We document policies, examine evidence, investigate institutional conduct, and publish findings. Our work addresses discrimination, exclusion, institutional transparency, and respect for Indigenous sovereignty.

Our Projects

BSA Accountability Project

Scouting America claims the Scout Law as its ethical foundation. We examine whether its national leadership, councils, chartered organizations, and programs consistently uphold those principles.

Our research addresses institutional governance, discrimination, membership trends, exclusionary policies, and the organization’s willingness to enforce its own standards.

OA Accountability Project

The Order of the Arrow has used Native American identities, imagery, terminology, and cultural practices throughout its history.

We examine the organization’s policies and practices, including its use of Indigenous cultural programming, its relationships with Native nations, and its accountability to the people whose cultures it represents.

Our Standard

Trustworthy first.

Claims require evidence. Policies require enforcement. Accountability requires public scrutiny.

The Scout Law is not merely a lesson for children. It is a standard against which Scouting’s institutions can be judged.

Loading spinner